Difference between revisions of "Team:HSHL/Human Practices"

 
(5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{HSHL}}
 
{{HSHL}}
 
<html>
 
<html>
 
+
<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://use.fontawesome.com/releases/v5.2.0/css/all.css" integrity="sha384-hWVjflwFxL6sNzntih27bfxkr27PmbbK/iSvJ+a4+0owXq79v+lsFkW54bOGbiDQ" crossorigin="anonymous">
<div class="column full_size judges-will-not-evaluate">
+
<h3>★  ALERT! </h3>
+
<p>This page is used by the judges to evaluate your team for the <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Judging/Medals">medal criterion</a> or <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Judging/Awards"> award listed below</a>. </p>
+
<p> Delete this box in order to be evaluated for this medal criterion and/or award. See more information at <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Judging/Pages_for_Awards"> Instructions for Pages for awards</a>.</p>
+
</div>
+
 
+
 
+
<div class="clear"></div>
+
 
+
 
+
  
 
<div class="column full_size">
 
<div class="column full_size">
 +
<a name="top"></a>
  
 
<h1>Human Practices</h1>
 
<h1>Human Practices</h1>
Line 19: Line 10:
 
At iGEM we believe societal considerations should be upfront and integrated throughout the design and execution of synthetic biology projects. “Human Practices” refers to iGEM teams’ efforts to actively consider how the world affects their work and the work affects the world. Through your Human Practices activities, your team should demonstrate how you have thought carefully and creatively about whether your project is responsible and good for the world. We invite you to explore issues relating (but not limited) to the ethics, safety, security, and sustainability of your project, and to show how this exploration feeds back into your project purpose, design and execution.
 
At iGEM we believe societal considerations should be upfront and integrated throughout the design and execution of synthetic biology projects. “Human Practices” refers to iGEM teams’ efforts to actively consider how the world affects their work and the work affects the world. Through your Human Practices activities, your team should demonstrate how you have thought carefully and creatively about whether your project is responsible and good for the world. We invite you to explore issues relating (but not limited) to the ethics, safety, security, and sustainability of your project, and to show how this exploration feeds back into your project purpose, design and execution.
 
</p>
 
</p>
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div class="column full_size">
 +
<h3>Interview with Mr. Leisner (LANUV)</h3>
 +
<p><i><b>Expert Interview with Mr. Leisner from the Ministry for Environment, Agriculture, Conservation and Consumer Protection (LANUV) of the State of North Rhine-Westphalia in Germany.</i></b></p>
  
 +
<p>To get some more information about the contamination of the soil in Germany and how to deal with it, we talked to Mr. Leisner. Before working for LANUV he studied horticultural. He is now an expert for agrology/soil science and the filtration of heavy metals out of soil.
 +
Talking about our project, we were able to ask him some questions concerning to our project idea, how realizable it is and if there are other options or ideas to approach this problem. </p>
  
<p>For more information, please see the <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Human_Practices">Human Practices Hub</a>. There you will find:</p>
+
</div>
+
<ul>
+
<li> an <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Human_Practices/Introduction">introduction</a> to Human Practices at iGEM </li>
+
<li>tips on <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Human_Practices/How_to_Succeed">how to succeed</a> including explanations of judging criteria and advice about how to conduct and document your Human Practices work</li>
+
<li>descriptions of <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Human_Practices/Examples">exemplary work</a> to inspire you</li>
+
<li>links to helpful <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Human_Practices/Resources">resources</a></li>
+
<li>And more! </li>
+
</ul>
+
+
 
+
  
 +
<div class="column third_size">
 +
<p><b>Mr. Leisner, which kind of heavy metals are in the soil of agricultural fields in Germany, especially in our area?</b></p>
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div class="column two_thirds_size">
 +
<p>Leisner: "In general, the contamination is getting higher as you get close to cities/industrial used areas. Due to the industry in the past 40-50 years and more and its dust pollution, you can find many heavy metals. But Cadmium and Lead are the most common ones, beside Zinc.
 +
But I have to say: Cadmium and Lead are more dangerous than Zinc because Zinc is not toxic for humans."
 +
</p>
 +
</div>
  
<p>On this page, your team should document all of your Human Practices work and activities. You should write about the Human Practices topics you considered in your project, document any activities you conducted to explore these topics (such as engaging with experts and stakeholders), describe why you took a particular approach (including referencing any work you built upon), and explain if and how you integrated takeaways from your Human Practices work back into your project purpose, design and/or execution. </p>
+
<div class="column third_size">
+
<p><b>So, are there already techniques to clean the soil?</b></p>
<p>If your team has gone above and beyond in work related to safety, then you should document this work on your Safety wiki page and provide a description and link on this page. If your team has developed education and public engagement efforts that go beyond a focus on your particular project, and for which would like to nominate your team for the Best Education and Public Engagement Special Prize, you should document this work on your Education and Education wiki page and provide a description and link here. </p>
+
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<div class="clear"></div>
 
  
+
<div class="column two_thirds_size">
<div class="column full_size">
+
<p>Leisner: "There are some techniques, but they are all expensive and difficult, also labor-intensive. There is, for example, the method of removing contaminated soil and replace it with clean one. But this is only for small areas, it is not realizable for agricultural fields. Also, the society concentrated much on the contamination of water and the air, but we did not think about the soil in the past. Another method is to pump out the ground water, use a carbon filter and pump it back. But this does not handle the problem with the soil – so your project idea could be a solution in a few years, since there is no adequate solution yet."
<div class="highlight decoration_background">
+
<p>The iGEM judges will review this page to assess whether you have met the Silver and/or Gold medal requirements based on the Integrated Human Practices criteria listed below. If you nominate your team for the <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Judging/Awards">Best Integrated Human Practices Special Prize</a> by filling out the corresponding field in the <a href="https://2018.igem.org/Judging/Judging_Form">judging form</a>, the judges will also review this page to consider your team for that prize.  
+
 
</p>
 
</p>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 +
 +
<div class="column third_size">
 +
<p><b>Does the public know about this difficulty in agricultural areas?</b></p>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
<div class="clear extra_space"></div>
+
<div class="column two_thirds_size">
 +
<p>Leisner: "Yes, we do – if there are problems of higher concentration of heavy metals we inform the public. We do professional public relation, but it is more about the private citiziens and their garden use than about the agricultural areas and the food. In that case we address the farmers and the chamber of agricultural directly. But when there are problems with the consumer protection, we inform the public, of course.
 +
Another point I want to mention now is that there are not only limits for agricultural used areas, there are limits for every place, e.g. for children playgrounds.
 +
An interesting fact, not many people know about:
 +
There is an information system for substantial soil contamination, not only heavy metals - (<a href="https://www.stobo.nrw.de/" target="_blank"> stobo.nrw.de</a>). There is plenty (more than thousands) data about the concentration of different substances in the soil. You can select the city or area you want to know something about and then the substance and the system gives you the required data."
 +
</p>
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div class="column third_size">
 +
<p><b>Last but not least: Do you think this project could turn out as the soultion?</b></p>
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div class="column two_thirds_size">
 +
<p>Leisner: "In general: yes! Since there is no suitable solution for the problem of contaminated soil in our area yet, I think you should follow this idea. You need to calculate how much heavy metals the tobacco plant can hyperaccumulate in one season and how long it will take to clean up the soil. Then you should talk to the farmers and chamber of agriculture, if this is realizable. But in my opinion: it is a great idea and I am curious what the progress of the project and the next years will bring in this discussion and the discussion about GMO plants or organism in general."</p>
 +
</div>
  
<div class="column full_size">
 
 
<h3>Silver Medal Criterion #3</h3>
 
<p>Convince the judges you have thought carefully and creatively about whether your work is responsible and good for the world. Document how you have investigated these issues and engaged with your relevant communities, why you chose this approach, and what you have learned. Please note that surveys will not fulfill this criteria unless you follow scientifically valid methods. </p>
 
  
 +
<div class="column third_size">
 +
<p>A huge thank you to Mr. Leisner and LANUV for having us in Essen and this informative conversation!</p>
 +
</div>
  
<h3>Gold Medal Criterion #1</h3>
+
<div class="column two_thirds_size">
<p>Expand on your silver medal activity by demonstrating how you have integrated the investigated issues into the purpose, design and/or execution of your project. Document how your project has changed based upon your human practices work.
+
<img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/e/e2/T--HSHL--interviewPhoto.jpg">
</p>
+
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
 
 
<div class="clear extra_space"></div>
 
 
 
 
<div class="column full_size">
 
<h3>Best Integrated Human Practices Special Prize</h3>
 
 
<p>To compete for the Best Integrated Human Practices prize, please describe your work on this page and also fill out the description on the judging form. </p>
 
 
<p>How does your project affect society and how does society influence the direction of your project? How might ethical considerations and stakeholder input guide your project purpose and design and the experiments you conduct in the lab? How does this feedback enter into the process of your work all through the iGEM competition? Document a thoughtful and creative approach to exploring these questions and how your project evolved in the process to compete for this award!</p>
 
<p>You must also delete the message box on the top of this page to be eligible for this prize.</p>
 
 
</div>
 
  
 
<div class="clear extra_space"></div>
 
<div class="clear extra_space"></div>

Latest revision as of 21:59, 17 October 2018

Human Practices

At iGEM we believe societal considerations should be upfront and integrated throughout the design and execution of synthetic biology projects. “Human Practices” refers to iGEM teams’ efforts to actively consider how the world affects their work and the work affects the world. Through your Human Practices activities, your team should demonstrate how you have thought carefully and creatively about whether your project is responsible and good for the world. We invite you to explore issues relating (but not limited) to the ethics, safety, security, and sustainability of your project, and to show how this exploration feeds back into your project purpose, design and execution.

Interview with Mr. Leisner (LANUV)

Expert Interview with Mr. Leisner from the Ministry for Environment, Agriculture, Conservation and Consumer Protection (LANUV) of the State of North Rhine-Westphalia in Germany.

To get some more information about the contamination of the soil in Germany and how to deal with it, we talked to Mr. Leisner. Before working for LANUV he studied horticultural. He is now an expert for agrology/soil science and the filtration of heavy metals out of soil. Talking about our project, we were able to ask him some questions concerning to our project idea, how realizable it is and if there are other options or ideas to approach this problem.

Mr. Leisner, which kind of heavy metals are in the soil of agricultural fields in Germany, especially in our area?

Leisner: "In general, the contamination is getting higher as you get close to cities/industrial used areas. Due to the industry in the past 40-50 years and more and its dust pollution, you can find many heavy metals. But Cadmium and Lead are the most common ones, beside Zinc. But I have to say: Cadmium and Lead are more dangerous than Zinc because Zinc is not toxic for humans."

So, are there already techniques to clean the soil?

Leisner: "There are some techniques, but they are all expensive and difficult, also labor-intensive. There is, for example, the method of removing contaminated soil and replace it with clean one. But this is only for small areas, it is not realizable for agricultural fields. Also, the society concentrated much on the contamination of water and the air, but we did not think about the soil in the past. Another method is to pump out the ground water, use a carbon filter and pump it back. But this does not handle the problem with the soil – so your project idea could be a solution in a few years, since there is no adequate solution yet."

Does the public know about this difficulty in agricultural areas?

Leisner: "Yes, we do – if there are problems of higher concentration of heavy metals we inform the public. We do professional public relation, but it is more about the private citiziens and their garden use than about the agricultural areas and the food. In that case we address the farmers and the chamber of agricultural directly. But when there are problems with the consumer protection, we inform the public, of course. Another point I want to mention now is that there are not only limits for agricultural used areas, there are limits for every place, e.g. for children playgrounds. An interesting fact, not many people know about: There is an information system for substantial soil contamination, not only heavy metals - ( stobo.nrw.de). There is plenty (more than thousands) data about the concentration of different substances in the soil. You can select the city or area you want to know something about and then the substance and the system gives you the required data."

Last but not least: Do you think this project could turn out as the soultion?

Leisner: "In general: yes! Since there is no suitable solution for the problem of contaminated soil in our area yet, I think you should follow this idea. You need to calculate how much heavy metals the tobacco plant can hyperaccumulate in one season and how long it will take to clean up the soil. Then you should talk to the farmers and chamber of agriculture, if this is realizable. But in my opinion: it is a great idea and I am curious what the progress of the project and the next years will bring in this discussion and the discussion about GMO plants or organism in general."

A huge thank you to Mr. Leisner and LANUV for having us in Essen and this informative conversation!

This wiki is designed by HSHL within the iGEM 2018 template.
Instagram | Twitter | University | Fundraiser | E-Mail