Line 175: | Line 175: | ||
<div class="collapse slide"> | <div class="collapse slide"> | ||
<h2><font size="5">Discussion with J. Testart</font></h2> | <h2><font size="5">Discussion with J. Testart</font></h2> | ||
− | We discussed with the EPFL team, Jacques Testart (famous French biologist) and the association Sciences Citoyennes about iGEM competition and synthetic biology. First completely hermetic to iGEM, Mr Testart then consider that some project iGEM, like ours and that of Lausanne, could be ethically responsible. Here is his answer to our first debate and starting of email exchange: | + | <br> |
+ | We discussed with the EPFL team, Jacques Testart (famous French biologist) and the association Sciences Citoyennes about iGEM competition and synthetic biology. First completely hermetic to iGEM, Mr Testart then consider that some project iGEM, like ours and that of Lausanne, could be ethically responsible. Here is his answer to our first debate and starting of email exchange:<br> <br> | ||
Translation of the mail : <br> | Translation of the mail : <br> | ||
− | “ Thank you for your message. First of all, I would like to remind you how much my colleagues from Sciences Citoyennes and I were pleased to meet you and appreciated your questions that demonstrate a rare responsibility. | + | “ Thank you for your message. First of all, I would like to remind you how much my colleagues from Sciences Citoyennes and I were pleased to meet you and appreciated your questions that demonstrate a rare responsibility. <br> |
− | Why am I "against" IGEM? As stated in the book, this event is done to disconnect technical performance from its possible consequences for society. "Everything is possible !" they say. May the best win. It is also a matter of teaching to students, in a fun way, that research is above all a competition, which reinforces the ideal of performance in relation to the meaning of innovations. The difficulties you have in finding an interlocutor (at the IGEM or in your school) who can help you with ethical questions show that these questions are irrelevant, and it is not the sponsors who will contradict me ... | + | Why am I "against" IGEM? As stated in the book, this event is done to disconnect technical performance from its possible consequences for society. "Everything is possible !" they say. May the best win. It is also a matter of teaching to students, in a fun way, that research is above all a competition, which reinforces the ideal of performance in relation to the meaning of innovations. The difficulties you have in finding an interlocutor (at the IGEM or in your school) who can help you with ethical questions show that these questions are irrelevant, and it is not the sponsors who will contradict me ...<br> |
− | I do not think that many students have been brought to a reflection like yours thanks to this experience. With my colleagues from SC, we greatly appreciate your commitments and wish to continue these discussions with you. | + | I do not think that many students have been brought to a reflection like yours thanks to this experience. With my colleagues from SC, we greatly appreciate your commitments and wish to continue these discussions with you. <br> |
− | Sincerely, JTTT | + | Sincerely, JTTT<br> |
− | personal website: jacques.testart.free.fr | + | personal website: jacques.testart.free.fr<br> |
− | + | <br> | |
− | + | ||
− | + | ||
− | + | ||
+ | Last published book:<br> | ||
+ | Au péril de l'humain. Les promesses suicidaires des transhumanistes.<br> | ||
+ | With Agnès Rousseaux. Seuil 2018 “<br> | ||
+ | <br> | ||
+ | <br> | ||
We are still discussing with him the ethical basis of the competition. We will continue until him or us succeed to join the opinion of the other! | We are still discussing with him the ethical basis of the competition. We will continue until him or us succeed to join the opinion of the other! |
Revision as of 14:45, 17 October 2018
Template loop detected: Template:Grenoble-Alpes
EVENTS