Difference between revisions of "Team:Cardiff Wales/Public Engagement"

 
(20 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
 
<h1>Human Practices: Education and Public Engagement Special Prize</h1>
 
<h1>Human Practices: Education and Public Engagement Special Prize</h1>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
<p> As a team, we attended several different outreach events to engage with the public, increasing their knowledge and understanding of our project and genetic modification, and improving our awareness of what the public's opinions are.
+
<p> As a team, we attended several different outreach events to engage with the public, increasing their knowledge and understanding of our project and genetic modification in general. In turn, we hoped to improve our awareness of what the public's opinions actually are.</p>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
<h3 style="color:green !important">Cardiff University open days</h3>
+
<h3 style="color:green !important">Cardiff University Open Days</h3>
The university runs several open days across the academic year, we were lucky enough to attend 3 open days to demonstrate plant infiltrations and communicate with prospective students about activities outside of their studies, such as iGEM. Many of the students and parents were amazed at an opportunity that Cardiff offered at undergraduate level and eagerly discussed our project including the ethical issues of GM, and also the projects potential effects.  
+
<p>
 +
The University runs several open days across the academic year, and we were lucky enough to attend 3 open days to demonstrate plant infiltrations and communicate with prospective students about activities outside of their studies, such as iGEM. Many of the students and parents were amazed at the opportunities that Cardiff offered at undergraduate level and eagerly discussed our project including the ethical issues of GM, and also the project's potential effects. </p>
 
  <br><br>
 
  <br><br>
 
+
<center>
 +
<img style="width:50% !important" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/6/61/T--Cardiff_Wales--OpenDayEmily.jpg">
 +
</center>
 +
<br><br>
  
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">3G Genetics Conference</h3>  
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">3G Genetics Conference</h3>  
This was the first event our team attended, and one of the most enriching. In deep and sometimes controversial discussion with the attendees, we observed great interest in our student led project and keen discussion of their views on Genetic modification. Many of the people we spoke to came from many years of study, or careers in science- they gave us great depth and knowledge on issues surrounding our project. On speaking with one attendee in particular, Miriam Knight, of Gwent Beekeepers association, led us to give more thought to our projects effect on Bumble Bees on application. For further research, we then looked to contact associations- leading us to integrate our human practices.  
+
<p>
 +
This was the first event our team attended, and one of the most enriching. In deep and sometimes controversial discussion with the attendees, we observed great interest in our student led project and keen discussion of their views on genetic modification. Many of the people we spoke to came from many years of study, or careers in science - they gave us great depth of knowledge on the issues surrounding our project. Speaking with one attendee, Miriam Knight of the Gwent Beekeepers Association, led us to give more thought to the potential effect of our project on bumblebees. For further research, we then looked to contact additional beekeeping associations - leading us to integrate our human practices. </p>
 +
<br><br>
 +
<center>
 +
<img style="width:50% !important" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/f/f1/T--Cardiff_Wales--3GConference.jpg">
 +
</center>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
 
   
 
   
Line 22: Line 31:
  
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">Techniquest </h3>
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">Techniquest </h3>
Techniquest is an interactive science museum located in Cardiff bay. They openly welcomed us to attend their operation earth event, which fitted well with theme of our project, the environment being the central discussion point of the day.  
+
<p>
Tiny children in large lab coats made for great fun for everyone at the event, for this we greatly extended our interactive activities to engage the public- both children and parents were excited to participate, exploring new concepts and giving us their own thoughts and opinions.  
+
Techniquest is an interactive science museum located in Cardiff Bay. They openly welcomed us to attend their 'Operation Earth' event, which fitted well with the theme of our project, the environment being the central discussion point of the day.  
 +
Tiny children in large lab coats made for great fun for everyone at the event, as we greatly extended our interactive activities to engage the public - both children and parents were excited to participate, exploring new concepts and giving us their own thoughts and opinions.  
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
The first stage of our activities was by far the messiest! Here, participants did their very own strawberry DNA extraction followed by a plant infiltration. After seeing some DNA, and finding our more about the basis of all living things, the participants then moved to learn about genetic modification on a basic level with our 3D printed plant model showing colour changes with new gene insertions into the plant genome. Finally, the last activity involved our feely boxes- a hidden object needed to be guessed with only using touch. These objects have all been genetically modified in research, and we discussed with the participants from what organism the foreign genes may have come from. At this point, we received the most stimulating discussions on our project and genetic modification on a whole.  
+
The first stage of our activities was by far the messiest! Here, participants did their very own strawberry DNA extraction followed by a plant infiltration. After seeing some DNA, and finding out more about the basis of all living things, the participants then moved to learn about genetic modification on a basic level with our 3D printed plant model showing colour changes with new gene insertions into the plant. Finally, the last activity involved our feely boxes - a hidden object needed to be guessed only using touch. These objects have all been genetically modified in research, and we discussed with the participants from what organism the foreign genes may have come from. At this point, we received the most stimulating discussions on our project and genetic modification on a whole. </p>
 
  <br><br>
 
  <br><br>
<h3 style="color:green !important">Talk with Sixth form students at Ysgol Bryn Elian </h3>
+
<center>
 +
<img style="width:40% !important" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/8/8b/T--Cardiff_Wales--TechniquestGirls.jpg">
 +
</center>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
As part of our human outreach a member of our team visited a secondary school in North Wales, to have a discussion with Sixth form students about the applications of GM and their opinions on using GM to produce crops. We discussed with the students about current commercial uses of GM, and how our project utilises GM plants as an alternative to chemical pesticides. As part of this the students were asked to fill in a short questionnaire, to note down their opinions on GM crops and any benefits they see from the use of GM crops. The response to the questionnaire was overwhelmingly positive with every student saying they agree with the use of GM to produce crops. And every student also said that they can see benefits from using GM crops, with the most common benefits noted being the production of more nutritious food, higher crop yields, longer shelf life of foods and the ability to grow crops in harsher environments. The students also discussed the concerns that they have with the use of GM to produce crops, the most common concerns were possible side effects on humans or other organisms, allergies and companies possibly over charging farmers for their GM product. Whilst several students said they have no concerns over the use of GM to produce crops, often stating that this is due to the strict laws surrounding the use of GM to produce food in the UK. Also, as part of the questionnaire the students were asked about how they think the public in general view GM. Many of students felt that the public are becoming more accepting of GM and that its starting to be viewed in a more positive light, whilst some of the students felt that there is generally a negative attitude towards GM which comes from a lack of understanding. This was a beneficial human outreach experience which allowed us to have a discussion with a group of young people about their opinions of the use of GM to produce crops
+
<h3 style="color:green !important">Talk with Sixth Form Students at Ysgol Bryn Elian </h3>
 +
<p>
 +
As another part of our public outreach, a member of our team visited a secondary school in North Wales, to have a discussion with sixth form students about the applications of GM and their opinions on using GM to produce crops. We discussed with the students about current commercial uses of GM, and how our project utilises GM plants as an alternative to chemical pesticides. As part of this, the students were asked to fill in a short questionnaire, noting down their opinions on GM crops and any benefits they see from the use of them. The response to the questionnaire was overwhelmingly positive with every student saying they agree with the use of GM to produce crops. Every student also said that they can see benefits from using GM crops, with the most common benefits noted being the production of more nutritious food, higher crop yields, a longer shelf life of foods, and the ability to grow crops in harsher environments. The students also discussed the concerns that they have with the use of GM to produce crops. The most common concerns were the possible side effects on humans or other organisms, allergies and companies possibly overcharging farmers for their GM product. Several students said they have no concerns over the use of GM to produce crops, often stating that this is due to the strict laws surrounding the use of GM to produce food in the UK. Also, as part of the questionnaire, the students were asked about how they think the public in general view GM. Many of students felt that the public is becoming more accepting of GM and that it's starting to be viewed in a more positive light, whilst some of the students felt that there is generally a negative attitude towards GM which comes from a lack of understanding. This was a beneficial public outreach experience which allowed us to have a discussion with a group of young people about their opinions on the use of GM to produce crops. </p>
 
  <br><br>
 
  <br><br>
<h3 style="color:green !important">Practices
+
<center>
 +
<img style="width:90% !important" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/a/a3/T--Cardiff_Wales--SchoolTalk.jpg">
 +
</center>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
<h3 style="color:green !important">Agronomist </h3>
+
<h3 style="color:green !important">Super Science Saturday! at the National Museum of Wales </h3>
A meeting with Jonathan Harrington, an Agronomist, greatly informed us of the current controls used widely across the UK and by farmers he advises. He discussed with us the current chemical spray commonly used, in particular: Neonicotinoids and Synthetic pyrethroids. It takes only 5 maize seeds treated with the Neonicotinoid spray to kill a single grey partridge, says Professor David Gouson, of Sussex University<sup>(1)</sup>. These are used in the UK on oil seed rape, and their toxins remain in the soil for up to a year, or longer over repeated use on a field. This year the EU banned the use of 3 neonicotinoids- but is this enough?
+
<p>
 +
Our final outreach event was at the National Museum of Wales, at Super Science Saturday. Again, we loved running our interactive activities to help the children. On completion of all the science activities and games, collecting stamps along the way, the children were given badges and prizes. Our stall involved strawberry DNA extraction, the use of the 3D printed leaf light, and feely boxes where the children had to guess what was in the box, and guess what we may do to genetically modify them. Again, this generated a lot of interest from children and parents alike. </p>
 +
<br><br>
 +
<center>
 +
<img style="width:90% !important" src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2018/8/89/T--Cardiff_Wales--SuperScienceSaturday.jpg">
 +
</center>
 
<br><br>
 
<br><br>
An article in the New Scientist highlights the depth of research on this type of pesticide greatly effecting bumble bee. The toxic residues make their way from the field into hives and greatly affect the number of new queen Bees, and reductions in eggs cell numbers in solidarity bee nests <sup>(2)</sup>.
 
Synthetic Pyrethroids, show great resistance by pests against their anti-feeding mechanism, and are also seen to be degraded by light, lowering their efficiency.
 
<br><br>
 
We were greatly surprised to find that 90-95% of winter cereals are sprayed with chemical pesticides, confirmed by a representative of NIAB, Norfolk's regional agronomist, Stephen Keach. This is greatly due to a huge price reduction in recent years due to the massive growth in the pesticide market, multiplying to accommodate the expansion in agriculture worldwide to meet the worlds increasing populations food demand.
 
<br><br>
 
On discussion Jonathan saw that the aims of our project, to replace chemical pesticide use, would avoid wiping out populations of beneficial insects, such as the carbide beetle, that current sprays wipe out giving rise to other pest populations. He also saw no reason ethically why farmers would be opposed to using a GM crop in the field- the only barrier being cost comparison against current methods. This is confirmed by a survey by Farmers Weekly, where 61% of the participating farmers favoured growing GM crops on their land <sup>(3)</sup>. Agriculture is a booming economic business, maybe the push for a cleaner, healthier environment needs to be in the form of increased taxation on chemical sprays.
 
<br><br>
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">Welsh Environment minister
 
As part of our survey we explored the cohort’s knowledge on current EU laws surrounding GM crops, and their opinions on a potential change post Brexit negotiations. Currently there is a solid legal frame work followed by EU countries under the commission directive of 2018, that aims to protect all residing populations of humans and animals, requiring safety assessment at EU level prior to a GMO being available to enter the market <sup>(4)</sup>. Alongside this, clear labelling is essential to enable all consumers and businesses to be aware of what they are buying.
 
<br><br>
 
The UK’s legislation on GM crops aims to protect the environment and people, at present only importuning GMOs but not legally allowing to be grown. According to the Huffington post, “30 million tonnes of GM animal feed is thought to be imported into Europe each year to feed pigs, poultry, dairy and beef cattle, as well as farmed fish. The UK imports an estimated 140,000 tonnes of GM soy bean and as much as 300,000 tonnes of GM maize annually for use as animal feed.” <sup>(5)</sup>. So, with a country so reliant in GMOs as imports, why not allow GMO use in the UK's agricultural industry? With recent Brexit negotiations, much speculation around these current laws has come to light in the media. One article stated that post Brexit the UK is offered the chance to take more advantage of GMOs, projecting Brexit will “flood” the country with American GMOs <sup>(6)</sup>.
 
<br><br>
 
We looked to find a clear answer as to whether Wales specifically would alter the current restriction upon the growing of GMOs. Hannah Blythyn, the Environment Minister told us at approach will remain the same. But we remain optimistic for future change as she believes an open mind should be kept on GM developments, detailed in the image below.
 
 
  <br><br>
 
 
We plan to meet with the Welsh Governments Plant Health team, under Hannah Blythyns order to discuss our project and GMOs in Wales.
 
<br><br>
 
<h3 style="color:green !important">Welsh Beekeepers’ Association </h3>
 
Contacting the Welsh bee keeper’s association was great in finding a clear understanding of the relationship between aphids and honey Bees, as well as the great effect current pesticides have upon bumble populations. Bee harming pesticides are found in 75% of honey worldwide<sup>(7)</sup> and newly developed pesticide, Sulfoxaflor used in 47 countries worldwide is currently under review for licencing in the UK. Likely be a replacement to the current Neonics, posing a great threat to bee populations. One experiment saw a reduction in the new generation population of 54% <sup>(8)</sup>. It is great to see developments to remove the current toxic and harmful pesticides, but we believe this should not be with another chemical that will not protects beneficial populations such as bumble bees and insects alike.
 
<br><br>
 
The WBKA, saw great opportunity in our correspondence and support on our study to demonstrate their capacity to help universities and students in research. To demonstrate this, we have produced an article about our project, and their support, which will be published in the next quarterly magazine.
 
<br><br>
 
Compiling the discussions with Tony Shaw, WBKA president and Jonathan Harrington, led us to bionomically analyse any effect our RNA constructs could foreseeable have on bees and predators alike. More details of these results can be seen on our bioinformatics page.
 
<br><br>
 
<h2 style="color:green !important"><center> References </center></h2>
 
<br><br>
 
<p>
 
(1) - Gardenorganic.org.uk. (2018). Neonicotinoids | www.gardenorganic.org.uk. [online] Available at: https://www.gardenorganic.org.uk/neonicotinoids [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(2) - Wong, S. (2018). Strongest evidence yet that neonicotinoids are killing bees. [online] New Scientist. Available at: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2139197-strongest-evidence-yet-that-neonicotinoids-are-killing-bees/ [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(3) - Gmfreeme.org. (2018). • GM polls in the UK. [online] Available at: https://www.gmfreeme.org/gm-polls-in-the-uk/ [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(4) - Food Safety. (2018). GMO legislation - Food Safety - European Commission. [online] Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/gmo/legislation_en [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(5) - Wasley, A. (2018). Revealed: How Genetically Modified Food Is Finding Its Way Onto Your Dinner Plate. [online] HuffPost UK. Available at: https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/andrew-wasley/genetically-modified-food_b_4794557.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer_us=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvLnVrLw&guce_referrer_cs=JrR-75edvMkbzN-ECZ7ztQ [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(6) - Hart, R. (2017). Brexit will flood the UK with genetic-modified American food - and it's about time too. [online] politics.co.uk. Available at: http://www.politics.co.uk/comment-analysis/2017/02/02/don-t-fear-genetic-modified-american-food-it-s-perfectly-saf [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(7) - Sheridan, K. (2017). Bee-harming pesticides in 75 percent of honey worldwide: study. [online] Phys.org. Available at: https://phys.org/news/2017-10-bee-harming-pesticides-percent-honey-worldwide.html [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
<br><br>(8) - Brooker, M. (2018). Farming News - New generation of pesticides can reduce bumblebee reproduction. [online] Farming.co.uk. Available at: https://www.farming.co.uk/news/new-generation-of-pesticides-can-reduce-bumblebee-reproduction [Accessed 3 Oct. 2018].
 
</p>
 
 
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
</html>
 
</html>

Latest revision as of 19:15, 16 October 2018

Human Practices: Education and Public Engagement Special Prize



As a team, we attended several different outreach events to engage with the public, increasing their knowledge and understanding of our project and genetic modification in general. In turn, we hoped to improve our awareness of what the public's opinions actually are.



Cardiff University Open Days

The University runs several open days across the academic year, and we were lucky enough to attend 3 open days to demonstrate plant infiltrations and communicate with prospective students about activities outside of their studies, such as iGEM. Many of the students and parents were amazed at the opportunities that Cardiff offered at undergraduate level and eagerly discussed our project including the ethical issues of GM, and also the project's potential effects.





3G Genetics Conference

This was the first event our team attended, and one of the most enriching. In deep and sometimes controversial discussion with the attendees, we observed great interest in our student led project and keen discussion of their views on genetic modification. Many of the people we spoke to came from many years of study, or careers in science - they gave us great depth of knowledge on the issues surrounding our project. Speaking with one attendee, Miriam Knight of the Gwent Beekeepers Association, led us to give more thought to the potential effect of our project on bumblebees. For further research, we then looked to contact additional beekeeping associations - leading us to integrate our human practices.





Techniquest

Techniquest is an interactive science museum located in Cardiff Bay. They openly welcomed us to attend their 'Operation Earth' event, which fitted well with the theme of our project, the environment being the central discussion point of the day. Tiny children in large lab coats made for great fun for everyone at the event, as we greatly extended our interactive activities to engage the public - both children and parents were excited to participate, exploring new concepts and giving us their own thoughts and opinions.

The first stage of our activities was by far the messiest! Here, participants did their very own strawberry DNA extraction followed by a plant infiltration. After seeing some DNA, and finding out more about the basis of all living things, the participants then moved to learn about genetic modification on a basic level with our 3D printed plant model showing colour changes with new gene insertions into the plant. Finally, the last activity involved our feely boxes - a hidden object needed to be guessed only using touch. These objects have all been genetically modified in research, and we discussed with the participants from what organism the foreign genes may have come from. At this point, we received the most stimulating discussions on our project and genetic modification on a whole.





Talk with Sixth Form Students at Ysgol Bryn Elian

As another part of our public outreach, a member of our team visited a secondary school in North Wales, to have a discussion with sixth form students about the applications of GM and their opinions on using GM to produce crops. We discussed with the students about current commercial uses of GM, and how our project utilises GM plants as an alternative to chemical pesticides. As part of this, the students were asked to fill in a short questionnaire, noting down their opinions on GM crops and any benefits they see from the use of them. The response to the questionnaire was overwhelmingly positive with every student saying they agree with the use of GM to produce crops. Every student also said that they can see benefits from using GM crops, with the most common benefits noted being the production of more nutritious food, higher crop yields, a longer shelf life of foods, and the ability to grow crops in harsher environments. The students also discussed the concerns that they have with the use of GM to produce crops. The most common concerns were the possible side effects on humans or other organisms, allergies and companies possibly overcharging farmers for their GM product. Several students said they have no concerns over the use of GM to produce crops, often stating that this is due to the strict laws surrounding the use of GM to produce food in the UK. Also, as part of the questionnaire, the students were asked about how they think the public in general view GM. Many of students felt that the public is becoming more accepting of GM and that it's starting to be viewed in a more positive light, whilst some of the students felt that there is generally a negative attitude towards GM which comes from a lack of understanding. This was a beneficial public outreach experience which allowed us to have a discussion with a group of young people about their opinions on the use of GM to produce crops.





Super Science Saturday! at the National Museum of Wales

Our final outreach event was at the National Museum of Wales, at Super Science Saturday. Again, we loved running our interactive activities to help the children. On completion of all the science activities and games, collecting stamps along the way, the children were given badges and prizes. Our stall involved strawberry DNA extraction, the use of the 3D printed leaf light, and feely boxes where the children had to guess what was in the box, and guess what we may do to genetically modify them. Again, this generated a lot of interest from children and parents alike.